Skip to content

Brooklyn Thanksgiving Takeout: Order Deadlines Before the Holiday Rush

Compare Poppy’s à la carte menu with Mill Basin Deli’s group dinners, including the dates that matter before November 26.

··3 min read
Read the story ↓Saves stay on this device.
Conceptual illustration of unpacking a Thanksgiving meal in a Brooklyn kitchen; not a pictured vendor menu.
Illustration: The BK Brief · Original AI-generated conceptual editorial illustration

For Thanksgiving takeout in Brooklyn, Poppy’s lists a November 21 ordering deadline and November 25 fulfillment. Mill Basin Deli advertises turkey dinners for groups of 10–12 or 14–16, with a discount deadline of November 18. These are two different ways to outsource the meal: choose individual dishes or start with a package.

Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, 2026. This comparison was checked November 17 and records published menus, not live inventory. Confirm that the supplier can accept your order before building the rest of the holiday around it.

Poppy’s: choose dishes, then collect on Wednesday

Poppy’s 2026 holiday menu lists a braised half turkey at $165 and a whole roasted chicken at $34. Mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole and apple-fennel stuffing are each $38; stuffing with sausage is $42. These are separate menu items, not an all-in dinner price.

Order by Saturday, November 21. Fulfillment is Wednesday, November 25 only, with delivery offered or pickup at Poppy’s HQ, 194 Columbia Street. Check the ordering system for the available window and delivery coverage. The page links reheating instructions, which are worth reading before committing oven space.

The URL contains “2023,” but the visible menu explicitly says 2026 and gives this year’s dates. Use the menu heading and order confirmation when checking the season. Ask how many portions each side supplies; a tray price alone does not settle the guest count.

Mill Basin Deli: compare the complete group packages

Mill Basin Deli’s holiday page lists a 10–12-person package at $389.95 and a 14–16-person package at $515.95. Each includes roast turkey, stuffing, coleslaw, candied yams, gravy, relishes, cranberry-pineapple compote and dinner rolls.

The advertised GIVE10 prices are $350.96 and $464.36 for orders placed by November 18, 2026. Carving, decorating and wrapping cost an additional $24.95. Treat the promotion deadline separately from the final ordering deadline, which the page does not establish.

Call 718-241-4910 or 718-241-4911 to arrange the order. The address is 5823 Avenue T. Pickup and delivery are advertised, but confirm holiday time slots, delivery coverage, taxes and the final bill directly. The listed turkey weights are raw weights; they should not be read as the weight of cooked meat delivered to the table.

Which option fits your guest list?

A package makes the comparison easier when everyone expects a similar plate. À la carte ordering gives you more control if the host is already cooking some dishes. Write down what is missing from your meal before comparing totals: main course, vegetables, starches, bread, gravy or dessert.

For a smaller household, ask about portions and leftovers before choosing a group dinner. For a larger gathering, do not stretch a supplier’s serving estimate just to hit a budget. Send ingredient and allergy questions to the kitchen before paying, including questions about sauces and garnishes.

If you want to cook the bird yourself, GrowNYC’s 2026 turkey list is a different resource: it identifies farm ordering and market collection arrangements, including Brooklyn pickups. A raw-turkey reservation is not prepared takeout.

Plan the handoff before the dinner

Save the order number, collection address, pickup window and contact telephone in one message for whoever is collecting. Ask whether food arrives hot, chilled or frozen, and request the vendor’s storage and reheating directions. Check that the containers fit your refrigerator and oven; outsourcing the cooking still leaves a receiving and serving job at home.

Keep dessert separate if that suits the group. Our Thanksgiving pie-order comparison covers bakery deadlines and walk-in uncertainty. If you would rather skip hosting, the Brooklyn Thanksgiving restaurant comparison covers a separate dine-in decision.

Before you order

Confirm the complete price, servings, ingredients, cancellation terms and exact fulfillment time. A published deadline does not guarantee that every dish remains available until then. Retain the supplier’s confirmation, especially when ordering before a promotional cutoff for collection the following week.

Last verified November 17, 2026. Practical details can change; check linked official sources before making plans.

Useful? Pass it down the block.Choose newsletter topics