For Thanksgiving 2026 pie in Brooklyn, Petee’s lists a November 22 ordering deadline, with an earlier cutoff possible. Four & Twenty Blackbirds says Thanksgiving preorders are sold out and plans a limited supply of walk-in pies. Those are different levels of certainty: an order confirmation reserves your purchase; an announced walk-in supply does not.
This two-bakery comparison was checked November 16, 2026. It is a practical shortlist, not a ranking or a claim that either shop has every flavor available now. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26. Open the bakery’s current holiday page before committing to a collection trip.
Petee’s: check the holiday ordering window
The Petee’s holiday shop accepts orders for November 23–26 and advertises a November 22 cutoff, subject to demand. Full-size pies including pumpkin, Hudson Valley apple and brown butter honey pecan are listed at $45; selected six-inch versions are listed at $20. A menu listing is not a guarantee that your preferred pickup slot remains available.
For Brooklyn, the holiday collection information names 505 Myrtle Avenue. Published pickup hours are 9am–9pm Monday through Wednesday and 9am–1pm Thanksgiving Day. Delivery is listed only for November 23 and 24. Confirm your address and available delivery arrangements through the ordering process rather than assuming every Brooklyn location is covered.
After the preorder cutoff, Petee’s says both locations sell remaining pies in arrival order. If having one specific flavor is essential, treat a successful advance order as a different plan from arriving after ordering has closed.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds: a walk-in chance in Gowanus
The bakery’s Thanksgiving FAQ says holiday preorders and local delivery are sold out. It plans limited pies for sale at store opening during November 22–26. The four listed holiday flavors are salted caramel apple, brown butter pumpkin, salty honey and bittersweet chocolate pecan, priced at $46 each for a ten-inch pie.
The Gowanus shop is at 439 Third Avenue. Its holiday schedule lists Sunday, November 22, 10am–7pm; Monday–Wednesday, November 23–25, 8am–7pm; and Thanksgiving Day, 8am–3pm. Published closing time does not mean pies will last until then.
The bakery recommends arriving early. That increases your chance according to the operator, but is not a promise of stock or a particular flavor. Existing preorder customers should follow their confirmation’s date and location; an alternative pickup location is not automatically a walk-in sales counter.
Choose certainty, price or flexibility first
For a host who needs dessert settled in advance, start by seeing whether an actual Petee’s order can be completed for the required date. For someone comfortable with changing flavors or bringing another dessert, a Gowanus walk-in attempt may fit. That is a planning judgment, not an assessment of which pie tastes better.
At the listed whole-pie prices, two $45 pies total $90 and two $46 pies total $92 before any additional checkout charges. Compare the sizes, ingredients and portions you need rather than treating those subtotals as equivalent servings. Ask the bakery directly about allergies and preparation conditions; a familiar flavor name is not an ingredient guarantee.
Put the pickup into the holiday plan
Assign one person to collect the order and give them the confirmation, selected address and pickup window. Before promising dessert to your host, decide what you will bring if the chosen walk-in shop has sold out. Carrying a pie box also deserves a simpler route than a day of unrelated errands.
Ask for storage and serving instructions for the specific pie you purchase. If someone else will transport it onward, pass those instructions along with the box. Keep pickup information distinct from the time dinner begins, especially when holiday counters close early.
For a restaurant meal instead, compare our Brooklyn Thanksgiving dinner options. For background on the Gowanus shop outside the holiday rush, read the Four & Twenty Blackbirds visit brief. Check current holiday notices again before traveling: this article records the published arrangements, not live stock.
