The Peter Luger Ritual: How to Order at Brooklyn’s 1887 Steakhouse

Peter Luger Steak House at 178 Broadway in Williamsburg has been a Brooklyn dining landmark since 1887. Known for its porterhouse and old-school atmosphere, the restaurant’s traditions and payment policies set it apart from other steakhouses. For those planning a visit, understanding how to order and pay is essential for a smooth experience.

A Brief History of Peter Luger

According to the official Peter Luger history, the restaurant opened in 1887 as Carl Luger’s Café, Billiards and Bowling Alley. The completion of the Williamsburg Bridge in 1903 made the location more accessible to Manhattan diners. In 1950, Sol Forman acquired the business, and it remains under the management of the Forman family. The steakhouse emphasizes a hands-on selection process for USDA Prime beef, as described on its website.

Making Reservations

Peter Luger is a popular destination, and reservations are strongly recommended. The restaurant can be reached at 718-387-7400 for bookings. Walk-ins may face long waits, especially during peak hours. For groups, advance planning is advised. Reservation policies and availability can change, so it is best to confirm directly with the restaurant.

The Classic Peter Luger Order

Many diners opt for the traditional group order, which has become a hallmark of the Peter Luger experience:

• Porterhouse for Two or More: The signature steak is served sliced and presented on a hot platter. The restaurant highlights its hands-on USDA Prime selection process.
• Thick-Cut Bacon: Often ordered as a starter, the bacon is served in substantial slabs.
• German Potatoes: These are pan-fried and served as a classic side.
• Creamed Spinach: Another staple accompaniment.
• Cheesecake with Schlag: For dessert, the cheesecake is typically served with a generous portion of schlag (whipped cream).

Menus and offerings can change, so it is advisable to check the current menu on the official website or by calling ahead.

Payment Policies: What to Know

Peter Luger’s payment policy is notably strict and differs from many other restaurants. According to the official customer portal, the following forms of payment are accepted for in-person dining:

• Cash
• U.S. debit cards
• U.S. checks with proper identification
• The Peter Luger Card (a proprietary house card)

Regular credit cards are not accepted for dining in the restaurant. However, credit cards are accepted for online ordering through the official website. This policy is longstanding and frequently noted in official materials. Guests should plan accordingly to avoid surprises at the end of the meal.

Location and Contact Information

Peter Luger Steak House is located at:

178 Broadway Brooklyn, NY 11211 Phone: 718-387-7400

The restaurant’s proximity to the Williamsburg Bridge has contributed to its enduring popularity. Directions, parking, and public transit options can be found on the official website.

What Makes Peter Luger Distinct

Peter Luger’s longevity and adherence to tradition distinguish it from other steakhouses. The restaurant’s history, family management, and unique payment rules contribute to its reputation. The focus on USDA Prime beef selection is highlighted in official materials. The classic menu and group-oriented ordering style have become part of the ritual for many visitors.

Practical Tips for Your Visit

• Reservations: Strongly recommended, especially for dinner and weekends.
• Payment: Bring cash, a U.S. debit card, a U.S. check with ID, or a Peter Luger Card. Credit cards are not accepted for in-person dining.
• Menu: The classic order includes porterhouse, thick-cut bacon, German potatoes, creamed spinach, and cheesecake with schlag. Menu items and prices can change.
• Group Dining: The restaurant is well-suited for groups, with the porterhouse for two or more as a centerpiece.
• Policies: Verify current menus, hours, prices, accessibility, and payment policies directly with the restaurant before your visit.

Before you go

Peter Luger Steak House remains a unique fixture in Brooklyn’s dining landscape, with traditions and policies that set it apart. For the best experience, plan ahead: make a reservation, review the current menu, and prepare for the payment policy. For the most up-to-date information on hours, menu offerings, prices, accessibility, and policies, contact Peter Luger directly at 718-387-7400 or visit their official website at peterluger.com.