OddFellows DUMBO: A Brooklyn Ice Cream Guide

OddFellows Ice Cream Co. in DUMBO is a Brooklyn-based scoop shop at 44 Water Street, offering a frequently changing menu of inventive ice cream flavors, including dairy-free and sorbet options. Open daily from noon, it suits families, groups, and dessert seekers exploring the DUMBO waterfront. Here’s how to navigate your visit, from ordering to dietary questions and making the most of the neighborhood.

What Is OddFellows DUMBO and Where Is It?

OddFellows DUMBO is the Brooklyn flagship of a local ice cream company known for creative, small-batch flavors. The shop is located at 44 Water Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201, in the heart of DUMBO—a neighborhood famous for its cobblestone streets, waterfront parks, and Manhattan Bridge views. OddFellows began in Brooklyn in 2013 and has since produced hundreds of rotating flavors, from reimagined classics to bold originals. The DUMBO location is a short walk from Brooklyn Bridge Park, Jane’s Carousel, and the East River ferry landing, making it a convenient stop during a day out.

How Do Rotating Flavors Work?

OddFellows is known for its ever-changing menu. The company has developed hundreds of flavors over the years, and the DUMBO shop typically offers a selection that changes regularly. Expect a mix of dairy-based ice creams, dairy-free options (often made with cashew or coconut bases), and fruit-forward sorbets. Flavors can range from familiar (like chocolate chunk or cookies & cream) to inventive (such as miso cherry or olive oil).

Because the menu rotates, there’s no permanent list. The best way to know what’s available is to check the in-store menu board or ask staff. If you have your heart set on a specific flavor, call ahead at 718-683-5755 to check availability. OddFellows’ website and social media sometimes preview current offerings, but in-person selection is the most reliable.

Ordering Tips: Sampling, Cups, and Cones

With so many flavors, choosing can feel overwhelming. OddFellows encourages sampling—just ask for a small taste of a few flavors before deciding. Be mindful of busy times and limit your samples to two or three to keep the line moving. Staff are used to questions and can suggest popular or unique picks.

Ice cream is served in cups or cones. Cups are practical for sampling multiple flavors (you can usually combine two flavors in a single cup), while cones add a classic touch. Waffle cones may be available for an extra charge. If you’re ordering for a group or want to try several flavors, consider a flight or a pint to go.

Dietary and Allergen Information

OddFellows offers dairy-free ice creams (often cashew- or coconut-based) and fruit sorbets, which may suit some dietary needs. However, the company explicitly states that its facility regularly handles tree nuts and cannot guarantee the absence of traces in any product. If you have a severe allergy, discuss your needs with staff before ordering and consider the risks.

Vegan and dairy-free options are often available, but not guaranteed at all times. If you have specific dietary requirements, call ahead or check the menu board upon arrival. Ingredient lists are available for most flavors, and staff can answer questions about bases and allergens. Gluten-containing flavors are sometimes offered, so ask if you need to avoid gluten.

Hours, Seating, and Accessibility

OddFellows DUMBO opens daily at noon. Closing time is 10pm Sunday through Thursday, and 11pm on Friday and Saturday. Hours may change seasonally or for special events, so check the official website or call ahead for the latest information.

Seating is limited inside, with a few tables and benches. During busy times, expect to take your ice cream to go. The shop is wheelchair accessible, but space can be tight when crowded. Strollers are common, but parking them outside may be easier on weekends.

Alcoholic Options and Party Info

OddFellows DUMBO has previously offered boozy ice cream flavors and adult milkshakes, according to Brooklyn Paper. Alcohol service and menu items change, so confirm availability if you’re interested in these options. The shop can host parties or group events, but terms, pricing, and reservation policies vary. Contact the store directly for current details if you’re planning a celebration.

Making OddFellows Part of a DUMBO Day

The shop’s location makes it easy to combine with other DUMBO attractions. After grabbing your ice cream, stroll to Brooklyn Bridge Park for waterfront views, or walk along Water Street to see the iconic Manhattan Bridge photo spot. Jane’s Carousel and the Empire Stores complex are nearby, offering more food, shopping, and public seating. The East River ferry landing is a short walk away, connecting you to other Brooklyn and Manhattan neighborhoods.

Parking in DUMBO is limited, so public transit or biking is recommended. The York Street F train station is a few blocks away, and several bus routes serve the area. Citi Bike docks are plentiful nearby.

Before you go

OddFellows DUMBO is a creative ice cream destination in a prime Brooklyn neighborhood, with a rotating menu and options for many dietary needs. Because flavors, prices, hours, and services change, check the official OddFellows website or call 718-683-5755 for the latest details before your visit. Enjoy your treat as part of a DUMBO waterfront walk, and plan for crowds on weekends and warm days.