Skip to content

At Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian, an Abolitionist Past Meets a Free December Concert

Fort Greene's 1857 abolitionist-founded church worships Sundays at 11 a.m. and opens its doors for free Jazz Vespers on Nov. 22 and a gospel concert on Dec. 6.

··4 min read
Read the story ↓Saves stay on this device.
Conceptual illustration of a twin-towered brownstone church at dusk with visitors arriving for a winter concert; not the actual Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church.
Illustration: The BK Brief · Original AI-generated conceptual editorial illustration

Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church, at 85 South Oxford Street in Fort Greene, holds Sunday worship at 11 a.m., in person and on livestream. Newcomers get two free ways in before Christmas. Jazz Vespers is on Sunday, Nov. 22, at 4 p.m., and the Lafayette Inspirational Ensemble's 35th annual Christmas Gospel Concert is on Sunday, Dec. 6, at 4 p.m. As of Nov. 17, the church had not posted Christmas Eve or other Advent worship times.

A church founded in the abolition fight

The congregation's history page says it was organized in 1857, just before the Civil War, and its heading calls it a "Temple of Abolition." Its first pastor, the Rev. Theodore Ledyard Cuyler, was an abolitionist. The church says he pressed President Abraham Lincoln to move quickly to end slavery. From its earliest years it also welcomed women to the pulpit, defying Presbyterian practice of the time. Speakers in the 1860s and 1870s included Amanda Berry Smith, a formerly enslaved woman.

That page lists more history. The Fisk Jubilee Singers gave a concert there in 1871. The poet Marianne Moore joined in 1935. Marian Anderson came in 1970 to honor the organist Melville Charlton. In the mid-1970s the church commissioned the Pratt Institute artist Hank Prussing to paint the "Mighty Cloud of Witnesses" mural. The National Fund for Sacred Places, which supports historic houses of worship, says the church hosted Frederick Douglass and Booker T. Washington. The church's own history page does not mention those visits. Readers interested in this era may also want to see how Plymouth Church in Brooklyn Heights presents its own abolitionist past.

The building and its organ

The church says on its building page that ground was broken in 1860 and the building was finished in 1862, with additions in 1885 and 1917. The National Fund describes it as a Romanesque Revival building with two towers, an open sanctuary with curved pews, and Tiffany stained-glass windows.

The organ is a fundraising priority. A February 2026 post about the pipe organ describes a four-manual, 56-rank Austin instrument from 1910. It sits in a mahogany case from an earlier 1886 Hook & Hastings organ, and the church says the organ is now only about 30 percent functional. The church is raising money for a combined sanctuary ceiling and pipe organ campaign. It has not published a timeline.

What a Sunday service is like

According to the church's Sunday service page, the liturgy follows the Reformed (Presbyterian) tradition. It also draws on older Christian practices and on the customs of a congregation that calls itself multiracial, multicultural and intergenerational. Music is central. The church lists the Lafayette Choir, led by J. David Williams, its director of music and organist, and the Lafayette Inspirational Ensemble, a gospel group founded in 1991 and directed by Janis Russell. The Rev. Emily Brewer is listed as pastor.

The congregation's weekly newsletter for Nov. 15 asked worshippers to enter through the lobby at 85 South Oxford Street. It said Sunday School is offered for ages 6 and up, with free childcare for younger children. The church doesn't publish rules on dress or Communion, so if those matter to you, call the office. Services stream on YouTube and Facebook, and past services are archived on YouTube.

Jazz Vespers and the Christmas Gospel Concert

The church describes Jazz Vespers as its own version of an evening prayer service, held on selected Sunday afternoons and curated by Craig Anthony Bannister. On the events calendar, the Nov. 22 service features the vocalists Janis Russell and Carla Cook. The church newsletter adds Mike Weatherly, poetry by Clara Freeman and a homily by Rev. Brewer. The newsletter says this service opens the series' 17th year. Doors open at 3:30 p.m., and admission is free, with a free-will offering.

The Annual Christmas Gospel Concert on Dec. 6 at 4 p.m. marks the Lafayette Inspirational Ensemble's 35th anniversary. There is no admission charge, though a free-will offering will be collected. It will also stream on YouTube and Facebook. The church sits between Fulton Street and Lafayette Avenue, so the concert pairs easily with an afternoon around the neighborhood. Our Fort Greene culture roundup has nearby ideas.

Advent and Christmas worship

As of Nov. 17, the church's special services page and events calendar did not list Christmas Eve, Christmas Day or other Advent services. The calendar shows regular 11 a.m. Sunday worship on Nov. 22 and 29 and on Dec. 6 and 13. If you plan to attend on Christmas Eve, check back in December or contact the office.

Before you go

Confirm Christmas Eve and Advent service times, which had not been posted as of Nov. 17. Ask about step-free entry and seating, because the church's website does not describe accessibility. Note that Jazz Vespers and the Christmas concert are free but collect an offering. The church office is open Monday through Thursday, 9 a.m. to 4 p.m., at 718-625-7515, or you can email info@lapcbrooklyn.org.

Last verified November 17, 2026. Practical details can change; check linked official sources before making plans.

Useful? Pass it down the block.Choose newsletter topics