Gage & Tollner: Book the Meal Before the Celebration

Gage & Tollner, at 372 Fulton Street in Downtown Brooklyn, offers advance arrangements for group meals and celebration cakes. If you’re considering this venue for a special meal, it’s important to understand how reservations, group dining, and cake orders work—especially if your plans involve a larger party or custom dessert.

Reserving Your Table: Individual and Group Bookings

Reservations for up to seven guests open 30 days in advance and can be made through OpenTable or the restaurant’s official reservation system. If you have a specific date in mind, such as a weekend dinner, set a reminder to book as soon as your preferred slot becomes available. Standard reservations are not accepted via the contact form, so use the designated platforms for these bookings.

For groups of eight to ten, a different process applies. You’ll need to email reservations@gageandtollner.com to arrange a prix fixe, family-style meal. This arrangement requires advance coordination, and the menu is set for these larger parties. If you’re organizing a work event or family gathering, factor in extra lead time and confirm all details directly with the restaurant.

Understanding Service Hours and Menus

Gage & Tollner’s hours and menus vary by day and time. Dinner is served Monday through Friday from 5pm to 10pm. On weekends, the restaurant opens earlier, offering lunch and dinner from 11am to 10pm. Brunch is listed as running until 2:45pm, but some menu pages reference a 3pm changeover. If you’re planning for brunch or lunch, confirm the exact menu and timing when you book. An interim menu is available from 3pm to 5pm on weekends, which may affect your options if you arrive during that window.

Ordering Cake for Your Celebration

If your event calls for cake, Gage & Tollner offers advance ordering with at least 72 hours’ notice. Cakes are for on-site enjoyment only, and outside food is not permitted. For example, a 6-inch cake serving up to eight is listed at $95 on the official menu, but prices and options may change. If you have dietary needs or want a different dessert, ask about current selections and customization when you place your order.

Menu Planning and Budgeting

Menu prices and offerings can change, so it’s wise to review the current menu before booking. Build your estimate from the dishes and drinks your party actually plans to order, then allow for tax and tip. For prix fixe group meals, request the latest family-style menu and pricing when you email for a reservation. If you have specific dishes in mind, confirm availability for your date.

Getting There and Accessibility

Located in the heart of Downtown Brooklyn, Gage & Tollner is accessible by multiple subway lines. For the smoothest trip, check current MTA directions and service alerts before heading out. If you or your guests have accessibility needs, ask the restaurant about step-free entry, interior routes, and any specific accommodations you may require. Describe the entrance, seating and restroom route you need when you contact the team.

Sunken Harbor Club: Separate Space, Separate Booking

The Sunken Harbor Club, located upstairs from Gage & Tollner, operates separately from the main restaurant. If you’re interested in visiting both spaces, clarify booking procedures and availability for each. Ask what arrangements are needed for each space instead of treating a restaurant table as a plan for the upstairs bar.

Before You Go

• Set a calendar reminder for the 30-day reservation window if your date is important.
• For groups of eight to ten, email well in advance to secure a family-style meal.
• Confirm your preferred dining service and menu for your chosen time.
• Place cake orders at least 72 hours ahead and check current pricing.
• Review the menu and budget for possible changes.
• Ask about accessibility and transit options for your group.
• Clarify any plans involving the Sunken Harbor Club.

For more on the neighborhood, see our Downtown Brooklyn retail guide or first-timer’s guide.

For another local plan, read How to shop Downtown Brooklyn’s retail corridors or A first-timer’s guide to Downtown Brooklyn.