Best Pizza in Brooklyn: A Style-by-Style Guide

Brooklyn is a pizza lover's paradise, offering a diverse array of styles that cater to every palate. Whether you're in the mood for a classic New York slice, a hearty Sicilian square, or a gourmet wood-fired pie, this guide will help you navigate the borough's best pizza spots without the pressure of picking a single favorite. Here’s how to plan your pizza crawl, highlighting the unique offerings of each location.

Slice vs. Whole Pie

When planning your pizza adventure, consider whether you want to enjoy a slice or a whole pie. Many pizzerias offer both options, but the experience can differ significantly. Slices are perfect for a quick bite while exploring, but if you're dining with friends or family, a whole pie allows for sharing and sampling different styles. Be mindful that some places may have limited slice availability during peak hours.

Classic Slices: Di Fara Pizza

Located in Midwood, Di Fara Pizza is a legendary spot known for its classic New York-style slices. The owner, Domenico DeMarco, has been crafting pizzas since 1965, and his dedication to quality ingredients shines through. Expect a wait, especially during weekends, but many agree that the experience is worth it. Check their cash-only policy before you go.

Sicilian Squares: L&B Spumoni Gardens

In Gravesend, L&B Spumoni Gardens serves up a beloved Sicilian-style pizza. Their thick, square slices are topped with a generous layer of cheese and a sweet tomato sauce. This family-friendly spot is perfect for groups, and they also offer a variety of Italian desserts. Be prepared for a bustling atmosphere, especially in the summer when outdoor seating is available.

Gourmet Pies: Lucali

For a more upscale pizza experience, head to Lucali in Carroll Gardens. Known for its wood-fired pies, Lucali emphasizes fresh ingredients and artisanal techniques. Reservations are highly recommended, as this cozy spot fills up quickly. Keep in mind that they have a cash-only policy, so plan accordingly.

Unique Offerings: Paulie Gee's Slice Shop

In Greenpoint, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop offers a creative twist on traditional pizza. With a variety of toppings and styles, including vegan options, this spot caters to diverse dietary preferences. The casual atmosphere makes it a great place for a quick meal, but be sure to check their hours and availability, as they can vary.

Trendy Vibes: Roberta's

Bushwick is home to Roberta's, a trendy pizzeria known for its wood-fired pizzas and hip ambiance. The menu features unique combinations and seasonal ingredients, making each visit a new experience. Expect a lively crowd, and consider making a reservation if you plan to dine in. They also offer takeout for those on the go.

Waterfront Views: Juliana's

Located in DUMBO, Juliana's offers stunning views of the Manhattan skyline alongside its delicious pizzas. Known for its classic New York-style pies, this pizzeria is a great spot for a leisurely meal. The atmosphere is family-friendly, and they accept reservations, which can help reduce wait times.

Traditional Favorites: Luigi's Pizza

In South Slope, Luigi's Pizza is a neighborhood favorite that serves up classic New York slices and whole pies. This no-frills pizzeria is perfect for a casual meal, and they offer a variety of toppings to customize your pizza. Check their hours, as they may vary, and be prepared for a relaxed dining experience.

Artisan Touch: L'Industrie

Finally, in Williamsburg, L'Industrie is known for its artisanal approach to pizza. With a focus on high-quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations, this spot is perfect for those looking to try something different. They offer both slices and whole pies, but be sure to confirm their current policies on reservations and takeout.

Before you go

As you plan your Brooklyn pizza crawl, remember that schedules, access, prices, and policies can change. It’s always a good idea to check the latest details directly with each pizzeria before you visit. Enjoy your culinary journey through Brooklyn’s pizza scene, and savor the diverse flavors that each location has to offer.