Anthony & Son: A Williamsburg Sandwich Guide

Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe on Graham Avenue is a Williamsburg staple for Italian-American sandwiches. With over 60 options, the menu can feel overwhelming, but that’s part of the fun. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, planning a group order, or looking for a hearty meal to split, there’s a strategy for making the most of your visit.

This guide breaks down how to navigate the menu, what to expect when you arrive, and how to plan for everything from dietary needs to neighborhood logistics. Here’s how to get the most out of Anthony & Son, whether you’re a first-timer or a returning fan.

Understanding the Menu: Proteins, Richness, and Vegetables

Anthony & Son’s menu is built around classic Italian-American deli fare, with a heavy focus on sandwiches packed with cured meats, chicken cutlets, and house-made combinations. The official menu (linked from their website) lists dozens of options, including:

• Cold cuts: Prosciutto, soppressata, mortadella, turkey, ham, and more.
• Hot proteins: Chicken and eggplant cutlets, meatballs, sausage, and grilled chicken.
• Vegetarian choices: Eggplant parm, mozzarella and roasted vegetables, and a handful of salads.

If you’re looking for something lighter, focus on sandwiches with more vegetables or opt for turkey and grilled chicken. For a richer meal, the chicken cutlet and meatball options are among the most filling. Many sandwiches come with cheese, oil, vinegar, and house spreads, so you can ask to customize for dietary preferences or to dial back richness.

Bread, Portion Size, and Splitting Strategies

Most sandwiches are served on Italian hero rolls or ciabatta, with the bread playing a big role in the overall experience. Portions are generous—many regulars recommend splitting a sandwich if you’re not especially hungry or if you want to try more than one variety. If you’re ordering for a group, consider mixing hot and cold sandwiches to keep everyone happy.

Anthony & Son also offers panini-style pressed sandwiches, which are slightly smaller and crispier. If you’re unsure about portion size, staff can help guide you based on your appetite and preferences.

Ordering, Pickup, and Wait Times

Anthony & Son is primarily a takeout shop, according to The Infatuation. You can order in person, online through their official site, or by phone. During peak lunch hours and weekends, expect a wait—especially for hot sandwiches. Online ordering can help you skip the line, but it’s wise to check current wait times if you’re on a tight schedule.

If you’re picking up for a group or catering, the shop offers a dedicated catering menu. For large orders, calling ahead is recommended. The shop’s hours are 8am–8pm Monday–Wednesday, 8am–10pm Thursday–Saturday, and 9am–6pm Sunday, but holiday hours can change, so always confirm before heading over.

Seating, Eating Nearby, and Neighborhood Planning

Anthony & Son is designed for takeout, with limited or no dine-in seating. If you want to eat nearby, Graham Avenue has benches and small parks within walking distance. McCarren Park is about a 15-minute walk north, making it a popular spot for picnics with your sandwich haul.

The shop is located at 433 Graham Avenue, close to the Graham Avenue L train stop. Street parking can be challenging, so public transit is usually the easiest option. If you’re planning to explore Williamsburg, Anthony & Son makes a convenient lunch stop before heading to local shops or parks.

Catering, Group Orders, and Special Requests

For parties, office lunches, or events, Anthony & Son’s catering menu covers sandwich platters, salads, and prepared foods. Orders can be placed online or by phone. If you have specific dietary needs—such as vegetarian, vegan, or gluten-free options—it’s best to call ahead to discuss what’s available and how items can be customized.

Allergy and cross-contact questions should also be directed to staff before ordering, as the kitchen handles a wide range of ingredients. The menu changes, so always double-check for the latest options and ingredient details.

Accessibility and Dietary Considerations

The shop’s official site does not specify accessibility features, so if you have mobility concerns, consider calling ahead to ask about entrance steps or counter height. For those with food allergies or dietary restrictions, staff can answer questions about ingredients and preparation, but cross-contact is possible in a busy sandwich shop environment.

Vegetarian options are available, but vegan and gluten-free choices are limited. Customizing sandwiches by removing cheese or choosing bread types may be possible, but always confirm with staff.

Before you go

Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe is a go-to for anyone craving a classic Italian-American sandwich experience in Williamsburg. With a vast menu, generous portions, and a takeout-focused setup, it’s ideal for quick lunches, group orders, or a picnic in the park. Remember to check current hours, menu updates, and holiday schedules on their official site before visiting. For the smoothest experience, order ahead during busy times, and don’t hesitate to ask staff for help navigating the menu or accommodating dietary needs. Whether you’re a sandwich enthusiast or just hungry for something hearty, Anthony & Son offers a practical, satisfying stop in the neighborhood.